Monday, November 28, 2016

I'll Bee There for You: Do Insects Feel Emotions?

     This article starts out mentioning a book written by Charles Darwin titled The Expression of Emotions in Man and Animal. In this book Darwin stated that insects "express anger, terror, jealousy and love." Nearly a hundred and fifty years later, this article explains that Darwin may have actually been onto something. Because bee's are incapable of expressing themselves by describing their emotions, the article states that researchers "look for evidence that the insects have the cognitive, behavioral and psychological building blocks that, when combined, can give rise to a complex phenomenon like emotion."
     An experiment was done by biologist Clint Perry of Queen Mary, University of London. Him and his co-workers trained bumblebees to be able to distinguish between a blue flower on the left side of a container and a green flower on the right. The blue flower contained a thirty percent sugar solution while the green flower had only unsweetened water. The bees were able to associate and recognize that the blue flower yielded the sugary solution. They then tested bee's on a single blue-green flower. Before releasing the bees near the flower, half of them were given a sixty percent sugary substance and the other half were not. The scientists noticed that when the bees were released, the half that had been given the sugar prior to the test flew must faster toward the blueish green colored flower than those bees that had not been given the sugar.
     Following the experiment to make sure that the bees weren't reacting this way as a result of a sugar high, they conducted the same experiment with different colors and types of flowers. The bees only reacted this way when the flowers were blue, green or somewhere in between.
     According to the article, the reason why the sugar amped bees flew faster toward the flower is because of something called optimism bias, which is the assumption that an ambiguous stimulus contains a reward. Perry's experiment suggests that those bees who had been given the sugar were more optimistic. The article explains that humans react the same way as well. Infants cry less if offered candy or something sweet. Sometimes adults cope with sadness with a peace of dark chocolate from their stash.
    This article was very interesting to me because I personally have wondered whither or not insects feel anything emotionally. I have actually worked for a pest control company before and have never had an issue killing insects because they've always creeped me out and I have never thought that they were ever emotionally "aware". But, this experiment is interesting to me because it suggests otherwise. The results yielded from the experiment give evidence that insects are much more aware than I thought. This experiment definitely has application to society as a whole because if people took the time to research this, maybe they would think twice about killing all insects that they come in contact with. Bees pollinate a very large percentage of crop in the world and are therefore very important to human life. This information could help bees to never face the possibility of extinction.
     I also thought that this article was very interesting because in my opinion, the expirements conducted were extremely ingenious. When i've wondered in the past whither or not insects have feelings, i've just always concluded that we will never know and there's no way to tell. But all it takes is someone thinking outside the box and conducting experiments and new theories and evidences are produced. This was a very interesting article to me and i'm glad I chose it.

Original Article: Jason G. Goldman
Article Response: Chad Barlow

22 comments:

  1. What an interesting study! I myself have several bee boxes in my backyard and my brother an i dable in bee-keeping. Its always very interesting to see the social dynamics of how the hive behaves (or bee-haves, sorry couldnt help myself) I would not be suprised if bees somehow contained answer to all of lifes mysteries. They are fascinating.

    A- WArdell

    ReplyDelete
  2. So here's the next question: Which animals can feel the biggest range of emotion? For example, are some more capable of empathy than others? Do some experience loss differently than others?

    -J Woods

    ReplyDelete
  3. this article is very interesting, I have always had a fascination with animals since I was young and always had a suspicion that animals had feelings.now that people are saying that insects have emotions, the odds that other kinds of animals having emotions would be much higher in my opinion. This study could be very influential in future studies of emotion in animals if it proves to be true.
    J-Kearns

    ReplyDelete
  4. This a cool article, i had a question though do they state in the article how they can potentially use Optimism bias with other insects and animal life to investigate the emotion an sense of various organisms?
    -Jacob C

    ReplyDelete
  5. I love this article! I've always really loved bees, there so curious and adorable. I have built a bee box that I leave out for wild bees to make a home out of. I love the information about how the bees are stimulated by the possibility of a reward. I have read a few articles explaining how some plants will reward ants and bees with nectar once they have helped to pollinate. So it's super beautiful how plants and insects are able to collaborate through giving one another something they desire.
    S.R

    ReplyDelete
  6. This is something that I have always wondered. Not only bees, but all insects. I find it extremely profound that plants and animals and insects have desires, and needs, and emotion (to some degree.) C.W.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This article was a very interesting read! I cringe away from insects, but I have always preferred to move them outside instead of kill them. Now I wonder if they are able to feel grateful that I move them back outside! I would love to learn more about this topic and I hope there is more research done regarding whether insects can feel emotions. Like anything else, emotions must have some reason for existing and I wonder why it would be beneficial for insects to have emotions.

    ReplyDelete
  8. On many occasions, I have wondered if insects have feelings, so this study is very interesting to me. It is really interesting to see people studying the behaviors of insects in order to try and understand if they feel emotions. Its one thing to try and understand how a human is feeling, because we can express ourselves using words. However, insects cannot, so it is a completely different ball game.
    -Mindy C.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Right from the title I was intrigued! The idea that insects could actually have feelings is very interesting. But the anticipation of a reward via the sugar is kind of a weird way to determine whether insects have feelings or emotion. I think the bees could be reacting to those colored flowers because of their association with sugars in it of themselves. They create a sugary honey so in my perspective it only makes sense for them to get to the sugar solution because of their jobs as bees. Nevertheless, very interesting read.
    -H.B.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ya I agree that it isn't proof that they feel all types of emotion that we're accustomed to as humans. But like the article said, since they can't verbally tell us what they're feeling or thinking, it's difficult to know. I think one thing that this test did do was give very convincing evidence that it's not just blank up there in the bee's little heads :) -Chad B

      Delete
  10. I do think it is interesting that the bees felt an "emotion" but wonder what other types of emotions they might feel and what emotions other insects might feel. I do know they have done experiments on dogs and found them to only feel a handful of emotions. I feel this study was well done but only focused on one insect and one type of emotion and I do not think that means insects feel emotion. Bees feel an optimism bias is all this study proved. Still interesting, but I would like to know more.
    -Alex G

    ReplyDelete
  11. Again, I am skeptical of the implications this article gives. Can we really base our understanding of complex human behavior on something as simple as how fast a bee flies? Saying a bee 'feels' anything that is remotely like human emotions is a bit of a stretch for me.
    -BG

    ReplyDelete
  12. I wonder how close this comes close to something like human emotion. It seems to me like the bees are just responding to the prospect of getting more sugar rather then feeling some sort of complex emotion. I think that this is just more of an instinctual drive.
    T Anderson

    ReplyDelete
  13. I think this article is interesting especially in light of the fact that bees are going extinct. I wonder if the bees understand that their friends and family members are dying?

    Skyler H.

    ReplyDelete
  14. This is a very neat article. If we can identify emotion in insects using very little "survey" type data, it may give a wealth of information to pursue better understanding emotion in humans. Or at least it may give us physiological avenues to pursue to better understand emotion in humans. Given the prevalence of emotional regulation challenges like depression, this could be a great line of research to pursue. -- D.S.

    ReplyDelete
  15. I've actually thought about this! I've even gone overboard to the point when I kill an ant, that it probably had a task in its hive to do, and they're all wondering where he's at. I also noticed that when (this is macabre, forgive me) I took a blow torch to those giant ant eruptions near the grass on the sidewalk outside of my house, the ants would erupt in mass hysteria and start running around in circles instead of running away and hiding. I think all things have emotions, they might not be as big as ours, but they experience fear, motivation, happiness, etc.
    HW

    ReplyDelete
  16. are bee different then any other animal? most animals use nose, feel, or taste to tell what something it. it sounds like this was more color based.... do bees see color. or could they just tell on the left side is the good stuff.. or smell the stronger scent? I'm quite intrigued.

    ReplyDelete
  17. If the bees could show optimism then couldn't they show rage? What if they people who were doing the experiment changed the flower that had the higher amount of sugar to the lower amount. They could look and see if the bees reacted confused after a long time of having the flower be sugar to suddenly be not as sweet. This experiment has opened many more opportunities to study insects behaviors.
    HS

    ReplyDelete
  18. This is so cute when because I think some insects are so cute like bees and lady bugs and the thought of them feeling emotions makes me really happy for some reason it is interesting and exciting I would love to do research on this topic with other insects and see what happens.
    Steph S.

    ReplyDelete
  19. I mean, it all makes sense! Think about it, why do bees sting us? Well, it's not because they like us, it is because they are protecting something they care about. in order to protect something enough to sting someone and risk their lives, don't you think there would be emotion behind it?
    A.G

    ReplyDelete
  20. LOVED this article! Bees are so great! But I have mixed feelings about this research, part of me believes it and part of me thinks it's not true. Maybe it's because I don't want to believe it but it sounds like the bees know where the sugar is so they go there not because of emotion. But there is a high possibility that these findings are correct! Very interesting.
    -B.N.K.

    ReplyDelete